Insights

FundsIndia Recommends: Religare Tax Plan: Invest

November 28, 2012 . Vidya Bala

Well-placed to gain from a recovery

If you are looking to avail tax deductions and are willing to hold some mid-cap stocks in your portfolio, then Religare Tax Plan will fit your bill. The fund’s return of 9.3 per cent annually over the last three years may seem lack luster but that is a good six percentage points over its benchmark BSE 100.

Why invest?

The fund’s ability to limit volatility, despite holding as much as half of its assets in mid caps inspires confidence. In the 2006-07 rally, tax-saving funds that held high exposure to mid caps bore the brunt of market correction. A number of them shifted their focus to large caps after that. But Religare Tax Plan has chosen to hold a good proportion of mid-cap stocks. It in fact has a higher allocation to this market-cap segment compared with its aggressive peer ICICI Pru Tax Plan.

We believe its ability to contain declines and yet, hold a quality portfolio of mid-cap stocks with healthy exposure to large-caps, will ensure the fund benefits from a rally. While such a rally may not happen anytime soon, the pockets of value in the mid-cap segment are likely to ensure that the returns are magnified when a re-rating happens.

Suitability

Religare Tax Plan is suitable for investors with some risk appetite. For those looking for pure large-cap plays, Franklin India Tax Shied may be a better scheme to go for. It is noteworthy that the fund will be subject to a three-year lock-in, given its tax-saving benefit under Section 80C. If you go for the SIP option, every installment will be subject to a similar lock-in. To avoid this, if you wish to invest lump sums, consider investing in 2-3 installments – either when you have surplus or when you see a broad market correction of over 5 per cent.

Consider holding a tax-saving fund in addition to traditional small saving schemes with tax benefits. This will provide a good hedge for the risks in equity.

Performance

Religare Tax Plan fares in the top three in the performance chart of tax-saving funds over a five-year period. Although returns are in single digits as a result of a high base five years ago (November 2007), it is still better than the average return of diversified equity funds as well the negative returns of key indices over this period. The fund also boasts of consistent performance, beating its benchmark 90 per cent of the times in the last three years, on a rolling return basis.Its consistency is also proved by its limited deviation from its mean returns, compared with ICICI Pru Tax Plan and HDFC TaxSaver. Its average one-year returns (rolling three-year period) at 22 per cent also suggests that it delivers high returns irrespective of point of entry. Its ability to contain declines was proved both in 2008 and 2011.Portfolio
Religare Tax Plan appears to be slowly building a portfolio of cyclical value-cum-growth stocks, from a more defensive stock up in end-2011. For instance, it has increased exposure to banking and financial sectors and cut down on software stocks. While FMCG continues to be in the top three sector holdings, it has pruned exposure to this space.All this augurs well with our theory that the fund is preparing grounds for gaining in a rally, albeit nothing visible in the near term. While the usual large-cap suspects of ITC, Lupin, HDFC Bank and TCS are present in the portfolio, there are also quite a few premium mid-cap picks such as VA Tech Wabag, Gujarat Pipavav Port and Bajaj Corp. Other mid-caps such as Kalpataru Power & Transmission, Tecpro Systems and Redington (India) Ltd., though, offer value.The fund is managed by Vetri Subramaniam.To know how to read our weekly fund reviews, please click here!

24 thoughts on “FundsIndia Recommends: Religare Tax Plan: Invest

  1. Basic question – other than the 3 year lock-in for a Tax saving fund how is it different from a diversified equity fund? From a diversification point they look similar. Why does the govt. recognize this for tax saving and not the other diversified funds?

    1. Good question Sheetal. Most tax-saving funds don a multi-cap cloth. To that extent their portfolio and strategy is no different. But the advantage that tax-saving funds have is the lock-in. That means they are unlikely to have unpredictable outflows. Investors hold on till the three-year period. That gives more leeway for tax-saving funds to bet on longer term strategies or taking some risks in the short term, without pressure of redemption, even if a strategy fails.
      But a fund house cannot ask the SEBI for all its funds to be ELSS. In that case, investors will not have the fundamental advantage of investing in mutual funds – which is liquidity. Looking at it other way, not having a lock-in urges other diversified funds to perform well as there is a threat of redemption if performance slips. You will actually see the difference in performance of the top diversified funds compared with tax-saving schemes. Just that your yields may seem overall superior in ELSS because of the the tax deduction. – Vidya

      1. Thanks for the details Vidya, so as I understand it is the 3 year lock-in that makes the fund eligible for tax breaks.

  2. I have a corpus fund of Rs 1500000 and would like to invest in HDFC MIP, RELIANCE MIP,BIRLA MIP 25 AND UTI MIP equally. I am 46 years and would like to withdraw (SWP) Rs 5000 PER MONTH from each fund after 2 years. If the fund gives 11% return pa how long the money last.

    1. Hi Venkatraman: based on your return assumptions, Rs 20,000 withdrawn every month will allow your money to last for about 200 months or 8.3 years. But we urge you to be conservative in your return estimate. Only a handful of MIPs have delivered such returns. For instance, among your fund choices, while Reliance MIP and HDFC MIP Long Term managed 11% returns over the last 8 years, Birla Sun Life MIP Wealth 25 and UTI Monthly Income Scheme managed only around 8.5% annually. MIPs are predominantly invested in debt and have only a fifth of their assets, or ever lower, in equities. Hence, do not expect returns to be high. – Vidya

        1. Venkataraman, you can. But if they are equity-oriented balanced funds they will be subject to stock market vagaries. Much would depend on your risk appetite. You may write to our MF advisory team or fix an appointment for a call back if you wish to discuss about funds appropriate to your risk appetite. Vidya

  3. Mam,
    i have invested a sum of rs. 50000/- in religare tax saving bond will i get deduction u/s 80C for this or not

    1. Hello Shubham, If you meant religare Invesco Tax Plan (mutual fund), yes, you would get 80C deduction. Tks, vidya

  4. Mam,
    i have invested a sum of rs. 50000/- in religare tax saving bond will i get deduction u/s 80C for this or not

    1. Hello Shubham, If you meant religare Invesco Tax Plan (mutual fund), yes, you would get 80C deduction. Tks, vidya

  5. I have a corpus fund of Rs 1500000 and would like to invest in HDFC MIP, RELIANCE MIP,BIRLA MIP 25 AND UTI MIP equally. I am 46 years and would like to withdraw (SWP) Rs 5000 PER MONTH from each fund after 2 years. If the fund gives 11% return pa how long the money last.

    1. Hi Venkatraman: based on your return assumptions, Rs 20,000 withdrawn every month will allow your money to last for about 200 months or 8.3 years. But we urge you to be conservative in your return estimate. Only a handful of MIPs have delivered such returns. For instance, among your fund choices, while Reliance MIP and HDFC MIP Long Term managed 11% returns over the last 8 years, Birla Sun Life MIP Wealth 25 and UTI Monthly Income Scheme managed only around 8.5% annually. MIPs are predominantly invested in debt and have only a fifth of their assets, or ever lower, in equities. Hence, do not expect returns to be high. – Vidya

        1. Venkataraman, you can. But if they are equity-oriented balanced funds they will be subject to stock market vagaries. Much would depend on your risk appetite. You may write to our MF advisory team or fix an appointment for a call back if you wish to discuss about funds appropriate to your risk appetite. Vidya

  6. Basic question – other than the 3 year lock-in for a Tax saving fund how is it different from a diversified equity fund? From a diversification point they look similar. Why does the govt. recognize this for tax saving and not the other diversified funds?

    1. Good question Sheetal. Most tax-saving funds don a multi-cap cloth. To that extent their portfolio and strategy is no different. But the advantage that tax-saving funds have is the lock-in. That means they are unlikely to have unpredictable outflows. Investors hold on till the three-year period. That gives more leeway for tax-saving funds to bet on longer term strategies or taking some risks in the short term, without pressure of redemption, even if a strategy fails.
      But a fund house cannot ask the SEBI for all its funds to be ELSS. In that case, investors will not have the fundamental advantage of investing in mutual funds – which is liquidity. Looking at it other way, not having a lock-in urges other diversified funds to perform well as there is a threat of redemption if performance slips. You will actually see the difference in performance of the top diversified funds compared with tax-saving schemes. Just that your yields may seem overall superior in ELSS because of the the tax deduction. – Vidya

      1. Thanks for the details Vidya, so as I understand it is the 3 year lock-in that makes the fund eligible for tax breaks.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.